Clicky

Editorial: There is a Solution to Modernizing Air Traffic Control

Care to share?

Last weekend, we saw a meltdown of the US Air Traffic Control (“ATC”) System during an apparently poorly planned switchover from copper wire to fiber optic cables at the 22 regional high altitude air traffic control centers. A solution exists to prevent future problems.

The Air Traffic Control Failure

The apparent failure to successful merge old and new technologies resulted in a nationwide traffic stop for the entire United States on a busy Friday afternoon. The FAA, and its contractor for the upgrade work, L3Harris, failed to anticipate the problems that overloaded the system. Those problems resulted in thousands of canceled flights.

Air Traffic Control
image FAA

Those cancellations stranded more than a million passengers, overcrowding airports. With today’s high load factors, re-accommodation of passengers is still an on-going problem on the Monday following the Friday failure, with every empty seat filling up with stranded passengers.

How could such a failure occur, given that the system is essential to safety. Whatever happened to parallel testing prior to a live changeover? This isn’t rocket science, and the situation reeks of incompetence. DOGE, the Department of Government Efficiency eliminated several hundred jobs at the FAA last year. Some were related to air traffic control, and the agency is now further understaffed.

Politics and Aviation – Not a Good Mix

As usual following a disastrous situation for passengers, politicians are blaming each other, past and present administrations, and a lack of funding for the situation. Requests for extremely high expenditures, including an outrageous FAA request for $50 billion (yes, with a B) to upgrade to a new system on top of an existing $15 billion budget.

For many years, administrations from both parties have essentially “kicked the can down the road” rather than to provide a concrete solution to the problem. With a system based on obsolete technologies and equipment that is no longer supported or produced, the probability of future failures is high and increasing. From government shutdowns to technical failures, the system is not as safe as it needs to be.

The FAA has become the focus of mismanagement in recent years. Clearly, the obsolete system is one result. The failure to properly certify the Boeing 737 MAX cost 346 lives. Subsequently, the failure to monitor Boeing production led to a door plug without fasteners falling from an aircraft. Fortunately, there were no fatalities, but at a higher altitude this would have been catastrophic. The litany of problems reflects an agency that needs better leadership and a hard correction.

Look North for a Solution

Canada, back in 1996, created an innovative solution. The country privatized the Air Traffic Control system into a non-profit corporation that managed the system, and charged fees to users of the system.

Solution
image Nav Canada

The structure of Nav Canada is unique, with industry as well as government representation on its Board. The company has focused on continuous investment into the Air Traffic Control and Air Navigation System. With those improvements, Nav Canada remains one of the most efficient and modern systems in the world.

Should we Privatize the FAAs Air Navigation System?

The system at Nav Canada works, and works well. Nav Canada was structured to insulate it from political interference. Seats on the board are appointed by users and government. Airlines and business aviation organizations have seats to ensure that user viewpoints are appropriately considered.

The Bottom Line

The FAA, frankly, hasn’t been able to accomplish its objectives in recent years. The latest debacle simply provides more evidence of incompetent management as a government-run operation. Privatization to a non-profit corporation, with the right incentives and governance, could deliver a workable Air Traffic Control system faster and less expensively than the current approach.

A successful model exists with our neighbor to the North. Since there is no US monopoly on good ideas, shouldn’t we add this to the list of possibilities? We believe it just might be the right solution to a long-standing problem.

Views: 0

About The Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.