Clicky

Premium: Concerns about the Boeing-Embraer Deal

Care to share?

On Embraer’s earnings call earlier this week, a statement was made that the proposed transaction between Boeing-Embraer would now close by the end of 2019, rather than the end of 2018 as previously stated. This indicates that there may be several areas that still need to be ironed out, and invites the possibility that the transaction may be further delayed or perhaps never be realized.

We have always had a number of concerns about the transaction. First and foremost, would adequate resources remain to support the business jet and military business once the commercial side is moved from Embraer to the proposed joint venture? It was indicated on the conference call that a good portion of the transaction revenue would be passed along to shareholders. We had hoped it would have been re-invested in the business jet and defense sectors to further strengthen the company’s competitive position in these key markets.

With respect to resources, Boeing

has made it clear that it covets the lower cost engineering talent in Brazil. But Embraer is organized quite differently than Boeing in its engineering function, with individuals specializing functionally rather than program by program. As a result, an Embraer engineer may have worked on avionics for the E2 Jets, multiple business jet programs and the KC-390 over the last few years. If this core of engineering talent is removed with the commercial programs, who will be left to support the development of new business jets and military programs? Additionally Boeing will be able to realize significant cost reduction synergies and gain access to production and certification capabilities for parts of its NMA and future single aisle programs.