Clicky

The MAX Inventory at Boeing will be Growing

Care to share?

One of the elements likely to be a fallout from the recent MAX 9 depressurization will be the speed at which Boeing can bring down its finished aircraft inventory and generate cash flow by delivering them to airlines.

As of January 7th, Boeing had 185 finished 737 MAXs in inventory. The distribution of those aircraft by model is shown in the table below.

MAX Inventory

Boeing

began producing the MAX 7 and MAX 10 last year in anticipation of certification by year-end and completed 29 aircraft. That certification is contingent on the FAA approval of a request for a waiver by Boeing to allow an already known safety issue to be installed on early models and fixed later when a permanent fix is available. Given the latest problem with the MAX 9, that waiver now looks much less likely to be granted, in our opinion.

The Boeing waiver request centers on the engine de-icing system and the engine nacelles made of composite materials. If the de-icing system is left in the on position longer than needed, the composite nacelles on the 737 MAX could overheat and lose strength. In the event of an uncontained engine failure, the weakened nacelle could fail and allow engine parts to penetrate the fuselage, causing an explosive decompression at altitude.

A previous generation 737-700 flown by Southwest experienced a similar failure on April 17th, 2018, when a failure of the left engine resulted in a damaged nacelle that enabled engine parts to break a window, causing the aircraft to depressurize. One passenger was partially sucked out of the airplane and fatally injured.

While uncontained engine failures are rare, they do occur. Twenty months earlier, Southwest had a similar failure on a flight from New Orleans to Orlando that also experienced a loss of cabin pressure and wing damage. Still, the crew could divert to Pensacola for an emergency landing safely.

Given the decompression accident on the MAX 9, we believe the FAA will be less likely to grant the exception for the MAX 7 and MAX 10. At a minimum, the attention of Boeing engineers in devising a fix will likely take attention away from fixing the existing nacelle and engine de-icing issues and delay certification of the two new models by several months. In the worst case, the FAA could refuse to grant the exception Boeing has requested, forcing the company to address the known issue before the aircraft are allowed to enter service. This could result in six to twelve months of additional work.

The problem with the nacelle issue is that it presents a single point of failure and adds to the workload for a pilot to monitor the anti-icing system more carefully. If a pilot were to turn on the anti-ice system but overlook turning it off when the aircraft emerges from known icing conditions, the nacelle strength could be weakened. As there is no warning system that the system has been on for an excessive period, this places another burden on the flight crew to manage during flight, increasing their workload in an era when automation to decrease pilot workload is the norm.

The bottom line is we may find the 29 aircraft from uncertified models not being delivered anytime soon. Without the waiver, we’re looking at a 2025 introduction for the MAX 7 and 10, which would impact Boeing’s production ramp-up and cash flow and interrupt airline delivery schedules, with a particularly severe impact on Southwest and United.
The MAX 8, MAX 8-200, and MAX 9 models in service will not be as severely impacted as the MAX 7 and 10. Nonetheless, additional delivery delays will likely occur as most of the 156 aircraft of those types are destined for China.