On a positive note, an new order was announced from Al Qahtani Aviation Company for 16 CS300 aircraft plus ten options. These aircraft will be operated by SaudiGulf Airlines, a newly launched Saudi Arabian airline. This order underscores continuing interest in the aircraft, and the firm order backlog is now close to 200.
Meanwhile we understand that Malmö Aviation AB of Sweden has agreed to be the first operator of the CSeries. We heard from Geir Stormorken, Chairman, Braathens Leasing. Malmö Aviation is preparing – in cooperation with Bombardier – to become the launch operator. The delays announced this morning push deliveries out approximately 12 months. While unwelcome, Malmö will cope by retaining its Avro RJs for another year – they remain fully confident in the CSeries program. Malmö Aviation operates out of Bromma, the environmentally sensitive City Airport in Stockholm. As such, reduced noise, lowered emissions and short airfield capability are crucial to future operations. Lowered fuel burn and longer range are the other chief CSeries features appealing to the airline. Mr Stormorken says they are pleased to note that the test flying so far confirms that the program will deliver on its promises in these respects.
On a negative note, Bombardier officially confirmed a CSeries program delay, which had been widely anticipated given the pace in flight testing. The CS100’s EIS is now scheduled for the second half of 2015, rather than late 2014, and will be followed by the CS300 aircraft’s EIS approximately six months afterwards.
While this delay should not dampen enthusiasm for the aircraft, it will result in a delay of positive cash flows from deliveries for a few more months, which could negatively impact short-term earnings expectations. It also narrows the initial entry into service lead for the CSeries over the A319neo, 737-7MAX, and Embraer E2jets, negating the advantage of potential earlier delivery positions. With the initial three years of production for the CSeries nearly committed, it would be difficult for Bombardier to now deliver a large order faster than Boeing or Airbus.
These days, delays in aircraft programs have become as frustrating as delays by airlines at a terminal gate — perhaps karmic retribution for airlines that seem to always tell passengers that “we’ll have more information every 15 minutes”, and do it repeatedly, during delays. The A380, 787, and now CSeries have emulated that process, and even the A350, which appears to be running smoothly, had a false start and an early delay. Yes, everybody appears to be late. But it doesn’t solve carrier’s need for lift, or the OEMs needs for cash flow generation.
While delayed entry into service for new airliners seems to have become the rule, rather than the exception, it is as frustrating to airlines and shareholders as maintenance delays are to passengers, particularly when several delays are stacked up each other.
The Bottom Line:
What will be the impact of this additional delay on Bombardier? If we look at the A380 and 787 as examples, the net effect should be minimal, except in the timing of cash flows. Apart from pushing positive cash flow further to the right, it should not impact the program, as their customers are standing behind the aircraft and their orders. Bombardier has a $4B line of credit available, and can certainly withstand any delay. But this needs to be the last delay in the program to avoid potential further risks of losing customers to Airbus or Boeing.