Clicky

Premium #256 – A Rebuttal To “Why Boeing’s CSeries Concerns are Justified”

Care to share?

An editorial opinion by Dr. Loren Thompson was published in Aviation Week and Space Technology entitled “Why Boeing’s CSeries Concerns are Justified.”  AirInsight fundamentally disagrees with that opinion and offers this rebuttal to the specious arguments presented. Dr. Thompson’s words are in italics.

“The one thing these critics all have in common is that they are not responsible to Boeing’s shareholders and stakeholders. Boeing’s management is, and what it sees in the C Series is a government-subsidized attempt to subvert its most important product line: the single-aisle 737 jetliner that has dominated commercial air travel for half a century. In fact, 737s are so ubiquitous that on average, one takes off every 5 sec. around the clock. Boeing

would like to keep it that way by continuously improving the product.”

  • “Critics” are not responsible to Boeing’s shareholders and stakeholders. That is not their function.
  • That there are two sides to the argument is obvious.
  • However, the facts (i.e. truth) of the matter is that Boeing did not and could not offer Delta what it asked for.
  • Ergo, whether the C Series is subsidized or not is irrelevant. Delta could buy anything from Boeing to meet its need. Delta defines its need, not Boeing.
  • Moreover, the Delta deal does not in any way hamper the 737’s success. Boeing has a backlog of about seven years on the program.  What plausible argument can Boeing make to prove the C Series has damaged their business?
  • If Boeing were to argue that the United deal is an example, then how does Boeing explain United’s decision to switch away from the smallest 737 to a larger model? The United decision validates an argument that the smallest 737 does not offer the economics needed, even after being enlarged by Boeing to improve its economics. Heavy old aircraft don’t cut it against lighter new-technology competitors.
  • Perhaps the most telling statement is that the Boeing 737 has dominated commercial air travel for half a century. A 50-year-old design cannot effectively compete with a new clean-sheet design, given technology changes over the last half-century.  From materials to engines to systems, the C Series is a more efficient aircraft leveraging high technology.  Had Boeing not spent $30 billion on the 787 program, it could have afforded a new aircraft to maintain a competitive advantage.

Ottawa and Quebec’s provincial government aimed to save Canadian jobs by destroying American jobs. And if their plan succeeded, they would undermine the most important franchise Boeing has, the 737 jetliner. The 737 is the only single-aisle transport Boeing makes, and the company’s market forecasts estimate that nearly three-quarters of the jetliners ordered worldwide over the next 20 years will be single-aisle aircraft.